return to: MA Projects | Previous Page

 

3.6.  Flight Management System:

  • Air Traffic Control:Consists of two long-distance controlling centers in Hanoi and Ho Chi Minh City , and a close controlling unit in Da Nang . These centers are equipped with machines and facilities that meet the standards of the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO). However, the control towers operate with poor and deteriorating equipment.  
  • Technical supports for navigation:
    • Aviation Information: up-to-date equipment enables response to situations and emergencies when needed.
    • Air Navigation: improvement necessary to assure safety and coverage of all flight routes.
    • Air Supervision: non-uniformed employees operate using old methods, and should be updated to insure safety of the passengers.  
  • Aviation meteorology center: Most equipment is non-uniform and underdeveloped. Replacement is taking place.  
  • Search and Rescue Operation: A Committee of Search and Rescue has been established. Training for search and rescue activities is conducted annually. The CAAV works closely with neighboring countries on safety procedures and numerous co-operation activities.

3.7.   Financing:  

Financing is the most serious challenge for Vietnam ’s civil aviation sector. Since 1975, the sector has been subsidized 100% by the government. Its financial and accounting mechanisms have been centralized and are totally controlled by the government. In addition, since the establishment of the Vietnam Airlines Corporations, the government has had to cover its losses, even though it is a monopoly. The Vietnamese civil aviation sector has been unable to profit or experience financial growth.  

From 1993–1997, the Vietnam civil aviation sector invested VND 947.6 billion, equivalent to 24.4% of the total state budget.[13] Of the 947.6 billion, VND 585 billion is invested in the Flying Information Region (FIR) construction project and 596.6 billion in other aviation infrastructure projects.[14]  

As part of a more comprehensive plan, Vietnam Airlines will receive financial support from the US Export and Import Bank (USEXIM), Overseas Private Investment Cooperation (OPIC), Airport Group International (US), the DAR group (UK), DIWIDAG (Thai-German), and Maeda (Japan). This support of USD$3 billion will be used to upgrade the infrastructures of the existing airports and to build new airports over the next ten years.

 

4.        Foreign Airlines’ participation in the international air transportation market of Vietnam Airlines:  

Participating frequently in the international air transportation market of Vietnam Airlines are 21 foreign airlines of 19 nations. These include 7 airlines of North-East Asia (primarily Cathay Pacific, Japan Airlines, and Thai Airways), 7 airlines of the South-East Asia (primarily Singapore Airlines and Malaysia Airlines), 5 airlines of Western Europe (primarily Air France, Lufthansa, Swiss Air), and one airline of Australia (Quantas).  

In general, these airlines operate in Vietnam under the form of a traditional agreement. Up to now, Vietnam has signed 41 agreements with other countries for both indirect and direct flights. Most of these airlines are more competitive than Vietnam Airlines.  

Five US airlines recently accessed the Vietnam market via code-sharing agreements, namely United Airlines, American Airlines, Delta Airlines, Northwest Airlines, and Continental Airlines. The civil aviation relationship between the US and Vietnam has thus begun. In July 2001, American Airlines signed an agreement with Vietnam Airlines to operate code-sharing flights,[15] which will start in 2002. According to the decision of the Department of Transportation, Delta Airlines will code-share with Air France to supply services to Ho Chi Minh City and Hanoi . Northwest Airlines will code-share with Malaysia Airlines and KLM Royal Dutch Airlines ( Holland ) to Ho Chi Minh City and Hanoi , United Airlines code-shares with All Nipon Airlines ( Japan ) and Thai Airways International and Lufthansa Airlines ( Germany ) to Ho Chi Minh City . In the short term, these three airlines can operate 21 round-trip flights to Vietnam .

 

 

B. US CIVIL AVIATION SECTOR  

The US has the most long-standing civil aviation sector in the world. Like such industrialized European countries as England , France , and Germany , the US civil aviation sector bore international characteristics from its early years, making it superior to travel by surface or sea.  

In 1944, along with improvements to the science and technology of aviation, the demand for air transportation increased dramatically. Recognizing this trend, the US , a key nation in international civil aviation, led the world in establishing the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO), and after that the International Air Transport Association (IATA).  

Since then, US civil aviation has been the strongest aviation force in the world. The US has a decisive influence on international aviation organizations and on regional and bilateral aviation agreements.  

The following milestones will provide more complete insight into the development of the US civil aviation sector:

1. After World War II:  

1.1.               Bilateral Aviation agreement with European Allies:  

During this period, the US signed bilateral aviation agreements with European Allies. These agreements strongly affected the political and economic life in European countries. The goods and financial aid from Northern America helped these countries recover after the war.  

US aviation was strengthened by the development of aviation technologies in First, Second and Third generation planes,[16] and by flight route networks all over the world. Flights covered North and South America , Europe , Asia , and Africa . The US market-share accounted for 80 percent of international aviation.  

1.2.               Bilateral Aviation agreement with defeated countries:  

After World War II, bilateral civil aviation agreements were signed between the US and defeated countries Japan , Germany , and Italy . The Japanese believed their airlines were poorly situated in their agreement. The agreement served to link American routes to Asia , and the US had a definite advantage in exploring these routes. During this period bilateral aviation relationships were totally beneficial for the US .

2. FROM THE 1960s TO THE 1970s:

From the mid-1960s to the 1970s, European and especially Asian aviation developed aggressively. International air routes covered all of Europe . Remarkably, the Asian market-share in international aviation increased 25–30 percent, the European market share increased 10 percent, and the US market-share fell 55 to 60 percent.[17]  

Despite the expansion of bilateral aviation relationships, countries were still limited to Fifth Freedom Rights. There was a new demand for control of the international air transport network. Recognizing this, the Carter Administration developed a new policy for international air transportation. This policy included aviation modernization and opening skies for free competition, leading to a new revolution in the structure of US aviation. While over 200 airlines suffered bankruptcy in the US due to this policy, many vigorous airline corporations were established with the strength to expand the world market. Among these airlines were American Airlines, United Airlines, Northwest Airlines, and Delta Airlines.

 

3. From the 1970s to the present:  

Global alliances have become a cooperate trend, a new requirement for airlines in the world. In response to the global demand for traveling, single airlines without a large network decided to join global alliances, and take advantage of opportunities for investment in more aviation markets. “Open Skies” has been the main US international air transport policy during this period.  

 

OVERVIEW OF THE US-VIETNAM AIR TRANSPORT MARKET

 

Despite the long suspension of diplomatic relations between the US and Vietnam due to the US trade embargo, the air transport market between the two countries has existed since the 1990s. Thanks to the “open-door” policy of Vietnam , which has stimulated investment, trade, social, and cultural exchange, the passenger market between the US and Vietnam has greatly expanded.  

The air transport market between the US and Vietnam is large and has great potential. To date, although there has been no direct flight route between the two countries, the number of passengers is increasing. This can be seen via data from 1993 to 2000.  Approximately 30,000 passengers traveled from the US to Vietnam in 1991. The volume multiplied by 5 times in 1997, accounting for 140,000 passengers from both the US and Vietnam .[18] In 2000, the total number exceeded 175,000.[19]  

Under the current market structure, more than 1 million Vietnamese are living in the US , accounting for 60% of the passenger volume between the two countries. These expatriates visit relatives in Vietnam and travel as investors and tourists. In addition, American tourists and US veterans account for 38% of the market share.[20] The remaining travelers are US investors, politicians, diplomats of both countries, and students on study tours.  

Despite difficulties obtaining visas to the US , it is believed that the US is still the biggest passenger market to and from Vietnam . With a GDP of 31,000 US dollars, each year around 60 million Americans travel abroad, while approximately 46 million foreigners visit the US . Over 10 million people travel each year between the US and Asia . The number of passengers traveling between Vietnam and the US accounts for only 2% of the Asian total. The number of passengers from Vietnam to the US is only 6% of the number of passengers from the US to Vietnam .[21]  

Taking into consideration the market structure and traffic growth since the 1995 normalization of relations between the US and Vietnam , the commercial and investment cooperation between two countries has not yet fully developed. This is partly because Vietnam has not yet been granted the Most-Favored-Nation status. It is believed that when the US-Vietnam Bilateral Trade Agreement comes into force and when the MFN status is granted to Vietnam , passenger traffic between the two countries will increase at a greater speed.  

Because there is no government agreement on air services between the US and Vietnam , none of their airlines has carried out direct air services. Until there is an agreement, code sharing is the temporary method.  At the moment, passengers traveling between the US and Vietnam are carried via intermediate points in Northeast Asia and Southeast Asia (Trans-Pacific service to the West Coast) or in Western Europe (Trans-Atlantic service to the East Coast). Passengers traveling between the US and Vietnam must use connection points, of which Taipei , Seoul , and Hong Kong account for 80%. Fifty percent of the US-Vietnam air passenger market is absorbed by China Airlines and Eva Airlines. Vietnam Airlines, thanks to the code-sharing contract with China Airlines, serves only 9% of the market.[22] The remainder is divided equally among Korean Air, Cathay Pacific, Singapore Airlines, and Asian Airlines.  

Not having direct flights has allowed airlines of the connecting countries to aggressively exploit the air services market between the US and Vietnam . This may cause disadvantages for direct services by airlines of the two countries in the near future. Moreover, present aircraft performance may hinder the non-stop options for airlines of Vietnam and the US , but make no difference for options provided by airlines currently exploiting the Sixth Freedom Right.[23] This will pose a definite challenge to US and Vietnamese airlines when they commence direct service in the coming years.  

The US-Vietnam Bilateral Conference on Civil Aviation was held in Hanoi from March 18–20, 1998 . The conference aimed to foster cooperation between the two countries in the air transport sector. It also aimed to strengthen relations on investment, commerce, and tourism, in the process of normalizing US-Vietnam economic relations.  

After the conference, both parties carried out consultations on the US-Vietnam Bilateral Agreement on Civil Aviation. The agreement is considered a basic foundation for opening a direct flight between the two countries.  However, there have been a number of lingering issues. On the one hand, Vietnam wants a temporary agreement with a deadline of 3 to 5 years, after which a complete agreement could be approved. Prior to this consummation, Vietnam must solve a wide range of problems on air safety, air services, training, customs, and aircraft leasing and purchasing, to name a few. On the other hand, the US wants an “Open Skies” agreement immediately to establish the long-term aviation relations between the two countries.  

In short, the air market between the US and Vietnam is very promising. The US has ignored this market for a long time, but “landing” the five biggest airlines will encourage rapid growth. It is expected that in 5 to 7 years, the market will catch up and displace the markets between Vietnam and Western Europe .  Nevertheless, because the governments of the US and Vietnam have not reached a civil aviation agreement, and because airlines of the two countries have not aggressively developed strategies and mutual cooperation, third country competitors are the ones currently benefiting in the air services market.



[1] The “General Companies 91” is the group of companies that were created following the Decision N.91/TTG of the Vietnamese Prime Minister enacted in March 07, 1994 . Each company belonging to this category includes in itself at least seven enterprises, which has a cumulative legal capital superior to 1,000 billion of VND. The establishment of each “general company” has to be approved by the Prime Minister.

[2] Source: Vietnam Airlines

[3] Ibid

[4] “Wet-leased” requires the leasing of operating pilots together with leasing the aircraft

[5] Block seats are seats exchanged between two airlines or sold to other airlines on a flight of one airline.

[6] Source: Data Department of CAAV

[7] Source: Vietnam Airlines

[8] Source: Vietnam Airlines Cooperation

[9] Ibid

[10] Source: the Vietnam Airlines Corporations

[11] Hanoi : the capital of the Vietnam

[12] Domestic airports such as Phu Bai and Nha Trang

[13] Data provided by Data Department of CAAV

[14] Ibid

[15] Code sharing is the method of cooperation, in which one airline accepts the other’s code on its certain flight as agreed and vice versa.  

[16] First generation: propeller-drive engine plan and electronic controlling system

   Second generation: jet-plane with low speed and semi-conducting system

   Third generation: supersonic plane with intelligent chip

[17] The “Tap Chi The Gioi” Magazine, January 2000

[18] Data from the Vietnam-US Bilateral Conference on civil aviation, Hanoi , March 28-10, 1998.

[19] Ibid

[20] Ibid

[21] Ibid

[22] Ibid

[23] The right of an aircraft of a country  to carry passenger, cargo, packages, and mail between two foreign countries via home country.

Top

Continue to Next Page